Jellies

Find smooth fruit and pepper jellies, from classic grape and apple cinnamon to jalapeño.

Shop all sweet spreads

  • Amish Country Store Apple Cinnamon Jelly 18oz (510g) with its prepared contents.

    Old-Fashioned Apple Cinnamon Jelly (18oz)

    Old-Fashioned Apple Cinnamon Jelly (18oz)

    $7.99 USD
    $7.99 USD
  • Amish Country Store Elderberry Jelly 18 oz (510g) with a serving of its contents.

    Elderberry Jelly · 18 oz

    Elderberry Jelly · 18 oz

    $7.99 USD
    $7.99 USD
  • Amish Country Store Concord Grape Jelly 18 oz (510g) with a serving of its contents.

    Old-Fashioned Concord Grape Jelly (18oz)

    Sold out

    Old-Fashioned Concord Grape Jelly (18oz)

    $8.99 USD
    $8.99 USD
    Sold out
  • Amish Country Store Muscadine Jelly 18oz (510g) jar with its prepared contents on warm wood.

    Old-Fashioned Muscadine Jelly

    Old-Fashioned Muscadine Jelly

    $7.99 USD
    $7.99 USD
  • Amish Country Store Plum Jelly 18oz (510g) jar with its prepared contents on warm wood.

    Old-Fashioned Plum Jelly · 18oz

    Old-Fashioned Plum Jelly · 18oz

    $7.99 USD
    $7.99 USD
  • Amish Country Store Jalapeno Jelly 18oz (510g) jar with a small serving and ingredient cues.

    Jalapeño Jelly · 18 oz

    Jalapeño Jelly · 18 oz

    $7.99 USD
    $7.99 USD