Fruit Butters & Honey

Smooth apple, peach, pumpkin and other fruit butters alongside pure honey and hot honey. Find a favorite for toast, biscuits, tea and everyday cooking.

  • Amish Country Store Home Recipe Apple Butter 9.5 oz (269g) jar with its prepared contents on warm wood.
    Best Seller

    Home Recipe Apple Butter (9.5 oz)

    Home Recipe Apple Butter (9.5 oz)

    $5.99 USD
    $5.99 USD
  • Amish Country Store Home Recipe Peach Butter 19oz (538g) jar with a small serving and ingredient cues.

    Peach Butter · 19 oz

    Peach Butter · 19 oz

    $7.99 USD
    $7.99 USD
  • Apple butter with no granulated sugar added, 9 oz jar beside fresh apple slices.

    Old-Fashioned No Sugar Added Apple Butter (9oz)

    Old-Fashioned No Sugar Added Apple Butter (9oz)

    $5.99 USD
    $5.99 USD
  • Miller’s Apple Butter, 18 oz, beside a small serving and fruit

    Miller’s Amish-Made Apple Butter

    Miller’s Amish-Made Apple Butter

    From $5.75 USD
    From $5.75 USD
  • Amish Country Store Home Recipe Cherry Butter 20 oz. (566g) with its prepared contents.

    Cherry Butter

    Cherry Butter

    From $7.50 USD
    From $7.50 USD
  • Amish Country Store Honey Sweetened Apple Butter 19 oz jar, with smooth apple butter and an apple wedge.

    Honey Sweetened Apple Butter (19 oz)

    Honey Sweetened Apple Butter (19 oz)

    $8.99 USD
    $8.99 USD
  • Amish Country Store Pecan Pumpkin Butter Net Wt 16oz (454g) jar with a small serving and ingredient cues.

    Pecan Pumpkin Butter · 16 oz

    Pecan Pumpkin Butter · 16 oz

    $7.99 USD
    $7.99 USD
  • 100% Pure Amish Honey – Yoder Bees; 2 lbs package shown beside a serving.

    100% Pure Amish Honey – Yoder Bees

    100% Pure Amish Honey – Yoder Bees

    From $10.99 USD
    From $10.99 USD
  • Pumpkin Butter | 9 oz & 18 oz

    Pumpkin Butter

    Pumpkin Butter

    From $5.99 USD
    From $5.99 USD
  • Stutzman’s Bee Yard Pure Honey 2 lb bottle beside a dish of honey and wooden dipper.

    Stutzman’s Bee Yard Pure Honey – Amish-Made in Iowa

    Stutzman’s Bee Yard Pure Honey – Amish-Made in Iowa

    From $6.99 USD
    From $6.99 USD
  • Dutch Gold Hot Honey – Sweet Heat for Every Bite; 12 oz package shown beside a serving.

    Dutch Gold Hot Honey – Sweet Heat for Every Bite

    Dutch Gold Hot Honey – Sweet Heat for Every Bite

    $11.99 USD
    $11.99 USD