Collection: Homemade Spreads & Butters
Jams, Jellies, and Butters, Oh My!
From sweet jams and tangy jellies to rich apple and pumpkin butters, this collection brings together the best of our time-honored Amish recipes. Each jar is handcrafted in small batches for exceptional flavor and quality you can taste.
Perfect for breakfast tables, holiday gifts, or a cozy snack on fresh-baked bread — these spreads are a taste of country tradition you won’t find anywhere else.
-
Banana Strawberry Jam | Sweet Old-Fashioned Fruit Spread | 18 oz
Regular price $8.99 USDRegular price -
Strawberry Rhubarb Jam | Sweet & Tangy Old-Fashioned Spread | 18 oz
Regular price $8.99 USDRegular price -
Miller’s Amish-Made Apple Butter | Local Small Batch Apple Spread
Regular price From $5.75 USDRegular price -
Miller’s Black Raspberry Jam | Authentic Local Amish-Made Spread
Regular price From $5.75 USDRegular price -
Strawberry Jalapeño Jam – No Sugar Added (9 oz) | Amish Country Store
Regular price $7.50 USDRegular price -
Black Raspberry Jam | Rich Old-Fashioned Berry Spread | 18 oz
Regular price $11.99 USDRegular price -
B-E-A-R Jam | Blackberry, Elderberry, Apple & Raspberry Spread | 18 oz
Regular price $8.99 USDRegular price -
Triple Berry Jam | Blackberry, Black Raspberry & Red Raspberry Spread | 18 oz
Regular price $8.99 USDRegular price -
Jalapeño Honey Mustard | Sweet Heat Country Mustard | 16 oz
Regular price $7.99 USDRegular price -
Miller’s Peach Jam | Authentic Local Amish-Made Spread
Regular price From $5.75 USDRegular price -
Miller’s Blueberry Jam | Authentic Local Amish-Made Spread
Regular price From $5.75 USDRegular price -
Cherry Preserves | Tart Whole Cherry Spread | 16 oz
Regular price $8.99 USDRegular price -
Cherry Butter | Smooth Homestyle Fruit Butter | 10 oz & 20 oz
Regular price From $7.50 USDRegular price -
Old-Fashioned Muscadine Jelly | Amish Country Store
Regular price $7.99 USDRegular price -
Strawberry Jam | No Sugar Added Fruit Spread | 8 oz
Regular price $6.99 USDRegular price -
Strawberry Jalapeno Jam 18oz
Regular price $8.99 USDRegular price
