Collection: Homemade Spreads & Butters
Jams, Jellies, and Butters, Oh My!
From sweet jams and tangy jellies to rich apple and pumpkin butters, this collection brings together the best of our time-honored Amish recipes. Each jar is handcrafted in small batches for exceptional flavor and quality you can taste.
Perfect for breakfast tables, holiday gifts, or a cozy snack on fresh-baked bread — these spreads are a taste of country tradition you won’t find anywhere else.

-
Hot Pepper Jam 18oz
Regular price $8.99 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Cherry Jam 8 oz - No Sugar Added
Regular price $8.50 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Apple Butter BBQ Sauce 16 oz
Regular price $8.99 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Cherry Butter 16 oz
Regular price $8.99 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Black Raspberry Jam 18 oz
Regular price $10.99 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Triple Berry Jam 18oz
Regular price $8.99 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Miller's Red Raspberry Jam - 100% Authentic, Local Amish Made Jam
Regular price From $5.75 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Miller's Blueberry Jam - 100% Authentic, Local Amish Made Jam
Regular price From $5.75 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Peach Jam 8 oz - No Sugar Added
Regular price $8.50 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Blackberry Jam 8 oz - No Sugar Added
Regular price $8.50 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Blackberry Jam 18 oz
Regular price $8.99 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Christmas Jam 18 oz
Regular price $8.99 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Cherry Preserve Juice Sweetened 16 oz
Regular price $9.99 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Peach Preserves 16oz
Regular price $8.99 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Plum Jelly 18oz
Regular price $8.99 USDRegular priceUnit price / per -
Muscadine Jelly 18oz
Regular price $8.99 USDRegular priceUnit price / per